1990
Class A - Jamal Mashburn, Cardinal Hayes-NYC
Class B - Bernard Blunt, Jamesville-DeWitt-3
Class C - Chris Sullivan, Avoca-5

1991
Class A - Terrence Rencher, St. Raymond-NYC
Class B - Craig Caldwell, Syracuse Nottingham-3
Class C - Lateef Duncan, Rensselaer-2

1992
Class A - John Wallace, Greece Athena-5
Class B - Eric Ebers, Buffalo St. Joseph-CHSAA
Class C - Matt Verkey, Mynderse-5
Class D - Tom McCulley, Batavia Notre Dame-5

1993
Class A - Felipe Lopez, Rice-NYC
Class B - Bob Lazor, Norwich-4
Class C - Danya Abrams, Hackley-1
Class D - Adonal Foyle, Hamilton-3

1994
Class A - Felipe Lopez, Rice-NYC
Class B - Zendon Hamilton, Sewanhaka-8
Class C - Ryan Cochrane, Cardinal O'Hara-CHSAA
Class D - Adonal Foyle, Hamilton-3

1995
Class A - Stephon Marbury, Lincoln-NYC
Class B - Ryan Blackwell, Pittsford Sutherland-5
Class C - Wally Szczerbiak, Cold Spring Harbor-8
Class D - Mark Blount, Dobbs Ferry-1

1996
Class A - Lamar Odom, Christ The King-NYC
Class B - Elton Brand, Peekskill-1
Class C - Damien Foster, Buffalo Traditional-6
Class D - Chris Moore, Park School-6

1997
Class A - Ron Artest, LaSalle-NYC
Class B - Elton Brand, Peekskill-1
Class C - Jeremy Logan, Salesian-1
Class D - Maurice Manning, Bridgehamton-11

1998
Class A - Anthony Glover, Rice-NYC
Class B - Dale Menendez, Westhampton-11, and Jermaine Hollman, Westhampton-11
Class C - Leonard Stokes, Buffalo Turner-Carroll-6, and Desmond Harod, Adelphi-NYC
Class D - Maurice Manning, Bridgehamton-11

1999
Class A - Ken Satterfield, Rice-NYC
Class B - Leonard Stokes, Buffalo Turner-Carroll-6
Class C - Toby Foster, Candor-4
Class D - Alpha White, Fort Ann-2

2000
Class A - Ben Gordon, Mount Vernon-1
Class B - Joel Suarez, St. Mary-CHSAA
Class C - Andre Logan, Poly Prep-NYC
Class D - Luke Graham, Hamilton-3, and Josh Courtney, Sherman-6