First-team selections only

1974-75
Large schools
Reggie Carter, sr., Lutheran-8
Jim Graziano, jr., Farmingdale-8
Wayne McKoy, soph., Lutheran-8
Mike Palma, sr., Rockville Centre St. Agnes-8
Bernard Toone, sr., Yonkers Gorton-1
Small schools
Roosevelt Bouie, jr., Kendall-5
Sam Copeland, sr., Fallsburgh-9
Jene Grey, sr., Sidney-4
Bob Trogele, sr., Somers-1
Kelly Young, sr., Montecello-9

1975-76
Large schools
Andre Battle, sr., Yonkers-1
Jim Graziano, sr., Farmingdale-8
Wayne McKoy, jr., Lutheran-8
Lowes Moore, sr., Mount Vernon-1
John Murray, sr., Maria Regina-8
Glenn Vickers, sr., Babylon-11
Small schools
Roosevelt Bouie, sr., Kendall-5
Hal Cohen, sr., Canton-10
Tom Krystofiak, sr., Dunkirk Mindszenty-6
Steve McDowell, sr., Lackawanna Baker-6
Cliff Warwell, sr., Candor-4

1976-77
Large schools
Marty Headd, sr., Syracuse CBA-3
Pete Holohan, sr., Liverpool-3
John Johnson, sr., Buffalo Nichols-6
Wayne McKoy, sr., Lutheran-8
Jeff Ruland, sr., Sachem-11
Stan Wilcox, sr., North Babylon-11
Small schools
Chris Jerebko, sr., St. Francis-6
Pete Rademacher, sr., Alden-6
James Robinson, sr., Woodlands-1
Kevin Vogt, sr., Fulton-3
Daymon Yizar, sr., Rye Neck-1

1977-78
Large schools
Tom Emma, jr., Manhasset-8
Rory Glasco, sr., West Babylon-11
Jim Johnstone, sr., Lewiston-Porter-6
Rodney McCray, jr., Mount Vernon-1
Scooter McCray, sr., Mount Vernon-1
Small schools
Rudy Charles, sr., Goshen-9
Andy Rogers, sr., Bloomfield-5
John Schweitz, sr., Waterloo-5
Eric Stover, sr., Schuylerville-2
Mike Trollinger, sr., Woodlands-1

1978-79
Large schools
Tom Emma, sr., Manhasset-8
Rodney McCray, sr., Mt. Vernon-1
Sam Perkins, jr., Latham Shaker-2
John Revelli, jr., Scarsdale-1
David Russell, sr., Bellport-11
Small schools
Gordon Enderle, sr., Cuba-5
Bill Harvey, sr., Hampton Bays-11
Mark Rzemek, sr., Lancaster St. Mary-6
Tony Traver, jr., Greenwich-2 
Don Wilcenski, sr., Mattituck-11

1979-80
Large schools
Bret Bearup, sr., Harborfields-11
Wes Correa, sr., Bellport-11
Matt Doherty, sr., Holy Trinity-8
Sam Perkins, sr., Latham Shaker-2
Clyde Vaughn, sr., New Rochelle-1
Small schools
Bill Bayno, sr., Goshen Burke-9
Dave Close, sr. South Seneca-5
Carl Johnson, sr., Bridgehampton-11
Elgin Riggins, sr., Lyons-5
Tony Traver, sr., Greenwich-2

1980-81
Large schools
G - Jim Runcie, sr., Hyde Park Roosevelt-1
G/F - Ricky Burton, sr., Mount Vernon-1
F - Lawrence Hall, sr., Buffalo McKinley-6
F - AndrewHawkins, sr., Malverne-8
C - Bill Wennington, sr., Lutheran-8
Small schools
G - Maurice Martin, jr., Liberty-9
G - Tom Sutryk, sr., Bath-5
F - Matt Krol, sr., New York Mills-3
F - Andy Moore, sr., Cuba-5
C - Dave Carlisle, sr., Hudson Falls-2