First-team selections only

1967-68
Bill Chamberlain, sr., Long Island Lutheran
Ron Gilliam, sr., Elmira Free Academy
Milton Horne, sr., Albany Schuyler
Roy Neal, sr., Syracuse Central Tech
Tom Riker, sr.,Oyster Bay St. Dominic's

1968-69
Sid Edwards, jr. Schenectady Linton
Bob Finney, sr., Peru
Donn Johnston, sr., Jamestown
Bill Kunze, sr., Glean Head Lutheran
Mark Wadach, sr., Syracuse Bishop Ludden

1969-70
Rick Cutler, jr., North Tonawanda
Bob Devins, sr., Utica Notre Dame
Dennis DuVal, sr., Westbury
Sid Edwards, sr., Schenectady Linton
Wade Pittman, jr., Newburgh Free Academy

1970-71
Luther "Ticky" Burden, jr., Albany Schuyler
Mel Montgomery, sr., Buffalo Kensington
Wade Pittman, sr., Newburgh Free Academy
Gus Williams, sr., Mount Vernon
Mike Young, sr., Mount Vernon

1971-72
Large schools
Frank Alagia, sr., Rockville Centre St. Agnes
Luther "Ticky" Burden, sr., Albany Schuyler
Terry Chili, sr. Jamestown
Earl "Bill" Tatum, sr., Mt. Vernon
Jimmy "Fly" Williams, sr., Glen Springs Academy
Small schools
Joe Dombroski, sr., Goshen Burke
Pat Dunlea, jr., Waterloo
Larry Erick, sr., Forestville
Mike Hanley, sr., Syracuse Sacred Heart
Billy Newton, sr., Alexander Hamilton

1972-73
Large schools
Fate Harris, sr., Buffalo Dougherty
Fred Lee, sr., Watkins Glen Springs Academy
John Pitts, sr., Hempstead
Jim Williams, sr., Buffalo East
Jim Town, sr., Glens Falls
Small schools
Paul Berwanger, sr., Cornwall
Doug Hobbs, sr., Sidney
Jo Jackson, jr., Sodus
Ray Morningstar, sr., Depew
Neal Stoczynski, sr., Cheektowaga JFK

1973-74
Large schools
Tom Hicks, sr., Smithtown St. Anthony's
Mitch Jones, sr., Rochester East
Mike Russell, sr., Buffalo East
Ricky Williams, sr., Buffalo Bishop Timon
Sam Williams, sr., Mount Vernon
Small schools
Peter Bronson, sr., Oakwood School
Matt Fay, sr., Patchogue Seton Hall
Gordon Johnson, sr., Bridgehampton
Chris Patton, sr., St. Francis of Athol Springs
Bill Truitt, sr., Lackawanna Baker