1999
Class A: White Plains 46, Colonie 43  
Class B: Southampton 55, Rochester Bishop Kearney 42  
Class C: Buffalo Traditional 61, Utica Notre Dame 51  
Class D: Millbrook 44, Fort Ann 31  
 
1998
Class A: Schenectady 61, Hempstead 51 
Class B: Westhampton Beach 56, Westhill 36  
Class C: Sidney 63, Watervliet 47  
Class D: Bridgehampton 67, Jasper-Troupsburg 33  

1997
Class A: McQuaid 69, Hempstead 55  
Class B: Westhill 64, Walter Panas 53  
Class C: Syracuse CBA 66, Lyons 54  
Class D: Bridgehampton 79, Hammond 55  
 
1996
Class A: Niagara LaSalle 77, Newburgh 66  
Class B: Peekskill 71, Rochester Franklin 62  
Class C: Buffalo Traditional 62, Mechanicville 48  
Class D: Bridgehampton 51, West Canada Valley 37  
 
1995
Class A: Niagara LaSalle 67, Syracuse Henninger 57 
Class B: Poughkeepsie 62, Amsterdam 53 
Class C: Peekskill 94, Buffalo Traditional 85 (OT)  
Class D: Maple Grove 61, Sugar Loaf 54 
 
1994
Class A: White Plains 65, West Genesee 60 
Class B: Norwich 49, Central Square 29 
Class C: Bishop Ludden 64, Mynderse 54  
Class D: Hamilton 59, Tuckahoe 39 
 
1993
Class A: Hempstead 55, Mount Vernon 54 
Class B: Norwich 56, Rochester Franklin 49  
Class C: Whitney Point 57,  Broadalbin-Perth 53  
Class D: Clyde-Savannah 76, Tuckahoe 66  

1992
Class A: Greece Athena 60, Liverpool 37  
Class B: Syracuse Fowler 79, Palmyra-Macedon 61 
Class C: Mynderse 85, Malverne 79 
Class D: Batavia Notre Dame 70, Bishop Grimes 58 
 
1991
Class A: Mount Vernon 80, Syracuse Henninger 65 
Class B: Syracuse Nottingham 72, Nyack 70 (OT) 
Class C: Watervliet 68, Livonia 58 
Class D: Prattsburg 80, Argyle 72 
 
1990
Class A: Hempstead 60, Mount Vernon 42 
Class B: Jamesville-DeWitt 60, Newark 52  
Class C: Rennselaer 80, Buffalo Traditional 68 
Class D: Alexander Hamilton 57, Avoca 54