1971
Gus Williams, Mount-Vernon-1

1972
Large - Earl Tatum, Mount Vernon-1
Small - Bill Newton, Alexander Hamilton-1

1973
Large - Jim Williams, Buffalo East-6
Small - Paul Berwanger, Cornwall-9

1974
Large - Tom Hicks, St. Anthony-CHSAA
Small - Chris Patton, St. Francis of Athol Springs-6

1975
Large - Bernard Toon, Yonkers Gorton-1, and Reggie Carter, Lutheran-8
Small - Roosevelt Bouie, Kendall-5

1976
Large - Jim Graziano, Farmingdale-8, and Glenn Vickers, Babylon-11
Small -- Roosevelt Bouie, Kendall-5

1977
Large - Wayne McKoy, Lutheran-8
Small - Damon Yizar, Rye Neck-1, and James Robinson, Woodlands-1

1978
Large - Scooter McCray, Mount Vernon-1
Small - Eric Stover, Schuylerville-2

1979
Large - David Russell, Bellport-11
Small - Gordon Enderle, Cuba-5

1980
Large - Sam Perkins, Shaker-2
Small - Carl Johnson, Bridgehampton-11, and Tony Traver, Greenwich-2

1981
Large - Andre Hawkins, Malverne-8
Small - Andy Moore, Cuba-5

1982
Large - Alex Agudio, Walt Whitman-11, and Tim Kempton, St. Dominic-CHSAA
Small - Maurice Martin, Liberty-9

1983
Large - Curtis Aiken, Buffalo Bennett-6, and Russell Pierre, North Babylon-11
Small - Bruce Lefkowitz, Edgemont-1

1984
Large - Shelton Jones, Amityville-11
Small - Matt Ryan, Miller Place-11

1985
Large - Darryl Walker, All Hallows-NYC
Small - Kevin Broderick, Oswego Bishop Cunningham-3

1986
Large - King Rice, Binghamton-4
Small - Troy Bowe, Bridgehampton-11

1987
Large - Greg Koubek, Shenendehowa-2
Small - Arnold Bernard, Our Saviour Lutheran-NYC

1988
Large - Malik Sealy, Tolentine-NYC
Small - Danny Tirado, Our Saviour Lutheran-NYC

1989
Large - Ken Anderson, Archbishop Molloy-NYC
Small - Ken Wood, East Hampton-11, and Marcus Whitfield, Buffalo Burgard-6